Kiki’s Delivery Service, flying, and gendered power.

I’ve been trying to process the symbolism behind the dirigible and Tombo’s flying machine in Kiki’s Delivery Service, and how we’re meant to see them when compared to Kiki’s natural flying.

Starting with the conclusions that are easy to come to, flying in this universe is a symbol of strength and power. It is also a uniquely female power, since only women can be witches.

In most media women’s power is either a nebulous “ability to control men with her sexiness” or a “success in a male-dominated traditional career.” The first is really only “empowerful”, feminine but not powerful, and the second is powerful but not feminine, since it carries with it the idea that masculine things (science, business, combat) are the powerful things, and that women only get close sometimes by learning how to do those masculine things. And yet here we see that flying is really, truly feminine AND powerful.

Every time Kiki takes off on her broomstick in front of a woman who hasn’t seen her do it before, that woman gazes after her with the most glorious look of delighted awe, and it seems to me that in these moments, they are recognizing that feminine power in themselves.

So what does it mean when men learn to fly as well?

We have two different examples of this: the dirigible, made and staffed entirely (as far as I can tell) by men, and Tombo’s bicycle-powered flying machine. The dirigible crashes pretty horrifically. Tombo is seen flying quite happily in the end credits. What’s the difference between the two?

My hypothesis is that the dirigible is supposed to be an example of men trying to brute-force a solution, applying “masculine” thinking to conquer and claim a feminine power. I mean, they basically strap their little carriage to a gigantic synthetic balloon full of stuff that floats and try to make it work. It seems somehow very removed from individual efforts– there’s no way a single person could manufacture something that massive. And something about the strict scientific approach seems to me to be ignoring the real reason flying works, in Kiki’s universe.

Flying is an intensely personal endeavor, in Kiki’s world, like painting. It’s a creative endeavor, requiring inspiration; it’s an individual endeavor, requiring self-confidence. It’s almost a spiritual endeavor. To fly by science instead of by creative inspiration is to miss the point– and thus the dirigible crashes.

Tombo understands flying, though. It’s a personal dream for him, self-liberation; it holds a sense of wonder. He builds his machine with his own two hands, in his garage, by trial and error, and it requires a huge physical effort to make it work. He has to train to have any hope of succeeding.

It seems to me that by taking the personal approach to flying, Tombo is embracing the feminine parts of the power, as opposed to trying to shortcut right to the power itself, and this is why he is so successful.

Now, I’m not really cool with gender essentialism, so I don’t really think there are strict “feminine” and “masculine” ways of approaching things. But in a culture that devotes obscene amounts of energy to making sure everyone believes and obeys the gender dichotomy, I really appreciate a movie that affirms feminine power over masculine power. Especially since it shows that feminine power is only as gender-segregated as our enforced societal roles– if you’re willing to accept the “feminine” parts of yourself, you can also discover in yourself this feminine power.

And that’s pretty cool.

(See my previous post on Kiki’s Delivery Service here.)

Advertisements

5 Responses to Kiki’s Delivery Service, flying, and gendered power.

  1. Fay says:

    Congratulations! “Gender Goggles” has been reviewed and added to Blogging Women. I am very pleased to have had a chance to read your blog, you are doing a wonderful job.

    It’s my pleasure to add another quality women’s blog to our directory.

    I wish you continued success.

  2. dollyann says:

    Aye, I’m sorry I was so late to getting to this. I leave for college tomorrow, so it’s been a little hectic. I wish I could say something insightful/Buddhist about all of his, but nothing’s jumping to mind… except that maybe the dirigible’s crash is also supposed to be an endorsement of peaceful methods of freedom as opposed to violent ones.

    When I get a chance, I’m going to do a link back to this page and your other KDS review. Oh, and congratulations on being added to Blogger Women! 😀 That’s awesome. 😀

  3. Emma says:

    I’m so glad I found this! I agree with your view on female vs masculine power in KDS. In many of Hayao Miyazaki’s films you’ll find there’s a running theme of female empowerment- it is the fairer sex that that makes the big decisions, controls (Princess Mononoke), or comes into great power (Laputa), terrorizes, finds a sense of independence and confidence (Spirited Away), of wonderment and responsibility (My Neighbor Totorro), of self-love and self-worth (Howl’s Moving Castle). There’s this theme and many others, (which I suspect are close to his heart) like his obsession with flying and things that fly. But more often than not, even with all her faults and clumsiness (The Return of the Cat) the female character is the strong, determined, guileless and immeasurably generous-hearted centre of a universe that recognizes, respects and reveres female power. All I can say is that…. Disney has a lot of catching up to do! A LOT 🙂 (though I don’t see them embracing girl power with the same enthusiasm or insight of Miyazaki’s stuff, so maybe it’ll never happen – but that’s another story)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: